Although this product has a wonderful texture, the colour is 'dirty biscuit' - much darker than I expected and no use if you're pale-skinned looking to neutralise pink eyelids. An honest description should always be given in my view (we all know how misleading colours can be online). I've managed to mix this with other products so my money wasn't wasted.

I have been using the original colour (number 2) for years and I only recently ordered this in number 1 just to see if that lightens my eyelids a bit more. It is too light for me so using sparingly (medium/tan in summer) but it still looks nice, on the top eyelids only! I love the texture, it sits just right and it blends seamlessly. I sometimes dust it with a bit of shimmer shadow, but it looks natural and great on its own, too. Number 2 is still my most favourite and I even use it as a concealer, although it is a bit too grey on my skin. But it is healing on my dermatitis (lower lid and around nose) and it keeps my eyelids matte without drying them. I wonder what 3 would look like.

Def looks natural. Its a little dark for me but its nice & smooth and doesnt crease.

I love this been using for years as a base eyeshadow

I only wear nude coloured eyeshadow and could not find it with my regular brands. This is perfect - right colour - right texture and easy to use. It is value for money because - 1. It is exactly what I wanted and I couldnt get it anywhere else and 2. It will last for ages

Underwhelmed but nice on the other hand in order to have a non drying product that evens out the eyelid color

INSTRUCTIONS WERE TO SHAKE WELL, BUT IT WAS SOLID SO DID NOT BUDGE.

Love this product, gives a natural finish and easy to apply